What to Look for in a Muncie Personal Injury Lawyer

May 8, 2025

Muncie sees its fair share of major injuries, whether from collisions with cars, trucks, or motorcycles, slip-and-falls, construction accidents, or other catastrophic events. Fortunately, a capable attorney could help you obtain full compensation when you have been hurt in the city through no fault of your own, but how do you select the right one? If you are seeking justice for an accidental injury sustained in the Muncie area, let Hensley Legal Group explain what to look for in a Muncie personal injury lawyer.

Questions Remain Your Best Means of Evaluating an Attorney

Many lawyers in Muncie may promise you top dollar for your injuries while making extraordinary assertions about their abilities, but questions remain your best means of evaluating an attorney. To that end, we would like to present some important topics for you to discuss with the candidates before making your choice.

Question 1. Why Should I Hire You in the First Place?

Though Muncie personal injury plaintiffs generally decide to partner with seasoned legal practitioners, you are certainly entitled to go it alone in the wake of a substantial injury, so it is incumbent upon any lawyer to convince you to hire him or her in the first place.

For example, potential attorneys should be able to point out that you could be at a significant disadvantage when it comes to dealing with the defendants’ insurance companies, who could exploit your relative inexperience to resolve your claim for less or deny it altogether. In contrast, a veteran Muncie personal injury lawyer will be better equipped to meet the insurance companies on a level playing field. This is a key reason why 85 percent of what those companies disburse goes to claimants with attorneys, and any attorney who can’t make that case to you may not merit consideration.

Question 2. How Much Is My Case Worth?

This is something of a trick question, since providing any answer could serve as a red flag. The truth is that there will probably still be too many variables at the time of your initial conversation for an honest lawyer to name a concrete figure, such as the circumstances leading up to your accident, the defendants to blame for it, and the insurance coverage that may be applicable.

Factors like these could heavily influence how much is available to compensate you or whether anything is available whatsoever. Obviously, a skilled attorney will endeavor to secure the largest settlement or verdict possible, but anyone who tells you exactly how much that settlement or verdict will be is being either naïve or deceptive, qualities that should absolutely be avoided in a Muncie personal injury lawyer.

Question 3. Will My Case Have to Go to Trial?

When confronted with an airtight case that conveys both the extent of your damages and the depth of a defendant’s liability, a sensible insurer may make a healthy offer rather than risk a worse outcome later on. Consequently, Muncie personal injury cases can often be negotiated prior to trial.

Yet because a trial could be necessary, particularly when squaring off against a stubborn insurance adjuster who refuses to act in good faith, it is critical to join forces with an attorney with a proven record of success in the courtroom.

And a battle-tested litigator could be beneficial even if your case does not have to go to trial. Indeed, an insurance carrier may be more likely to be generous with a lawyer who can credibly threaten to go before a judge and jury instead of a lawyer who consistently accepts lower proposals out of fear, and you could end up with more money in your pocket as a result.

Question 4. What Does It Cost to Retain You?

Since most personal injury attorneys operate on a contingency basis, it should cost you nothing up front to retain them. Only after your case has been won should reimbursement be sought for out-of-pocket expenses and a fee for services rendered, usually as a percentage of the funds you have been awarded – which are statistically much higher with a lawyer in your corner.

In light of how typical this fee structure is, you should be wary of any Muncie personal injury attorney who insists on payment before getting started, as it may cast doubt on that attorney’s intentions and his or her faith in your case.

Reach Out to Our Knowledgeable Muncie Personal Injury Lawyers Now

Hensley Legal Group has been standing up for hardworking Hoosiers like you since 1998. If you have been badly injured in Muncie because of someone else’s wrongdoing, reach out to our knowledgeable Muncie personal injury lawyers now to explore your legal options.

You can call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form to schedule a free case review with a dedicated Muncie personal injury attorney.