Do I Need an Evansville Motorcycle Accident Lawyer for a Motorcycle Accident?

October 30, 2025

Though motorcycle accidents on Evansville roads like I-69 are less common than car or truck accidents, they can be considerably more hazardous, with riders facing five times the rate of injury and 28 times the rate of death in the event of a crash. However, compensation may be available if you get hurt while riding a motorcycle in Evansville because of somebody else’s misconduct, and retaining skilled legal assistance could increase the amount you obtain. Learn how hiring an attorney can help if you are wondering “Do I need an Evansville motorcycle accident lawyer for a motorcycle accident?”

Handling Your Own Case Could Put You at a Serious Disadvantage

While you are certainly entitled to go it alone following an Evansville motorcycle accident, handling your own case could put you at a serious disadvantage in various ways.

Any personal injury claim must allege two essential elements: negligence – the failure to exercise sufficient care so as not to inflict harm – and damages – the consequences of that negligence. Basically, if you incur physical damages as a result of a defendant’s negligence, you could go after that defendant for financial damages.

Yet merely identifying every defendant whose negligence played a role in your motorcycle accident can be challenging. Aside from the driver who hit you and the owner of his or her vehicle (if separate from the driver), other individuals and entities might share blame too, very often more than one simultaneously, and you could be barred from full recovery if you don’t pursue them all within the time allotted by law.

Even if you do track down each of the defendants, you might still encounter stiff opposition from their insurers, who could exploit negative sentiments about the perceived recklessness of riders and your unfamiliarity with the claims process to justify paying you less than your claim is worth.

To make matters worse, you might not really know what your claim is worth because you probably haven’t had to calculate injuries in dollars and cents before and may therefore be unable to tell whether a proposal for them is too low. Moreover, your current injuries might only represent a fraction of your total losses anyway, since some injuries may not be readily apparent, other complications might develop later, and so-called “non-economic” damages could sometimes end up being more detrimental and more enduring. As such, if you agree to an offer that doesn’t reflect the true costs of your motorcycle accident, you could get stuck holding the bill when they finally emerge.

What an Evansville Motorcycle Accident Attorney Can Do for You

This is when a knowledgeable Evansville motorcycle accident attorney can make a difference. Just as it won’t be the first accident for the insurance companies, neither will it be the first for the kind of seasoned lawyer you’d find at Hensley Legal Group, PC, a dedicated Indiana personal injury law firm whose experienced attorneys have been fighting on behalf of the wrongfully injured since 1998.

An Evansville motorcycle accident lawyer will be better equipped to fend off the tricks and tactics that might otherwise be deployed against you. An attorney will also be better equipped to assess the actual value of your case and will strive to equal or exceed that figure by moving swiftly to establish valid claims and/or file suit against every viable defendant and amass such critical evidentiary materials as:

Police reports
Citations and dispositions
Witness statements
Crash site photos
Dash cam, streetlight, and surveillance footage
Black box data
Phone records
Driving histories
Maintenance logs
Forensic analysis and accident reconstruction

When confronted with irrefutable proof of both the extent of your losses and the depth of the defendants’ liability, a sensible insurance carrier may choose to tender a generous settlement rather than risk a disastrous verdict. This is a key reason why injured victims receive 3.5 times more on average with lawyers than they do without them as well as why Evansville motorcycle accident cases are frequently resolved prior to trial.

Nevertheless, a battle-tested litigator will be indispensable if your case has its day in court, where approximately 96 percent of plaintiffs who represent themselves lose but plaintiffs with professional representation are favored to win. And if your attorney can convey to a receptive jury everything that your Evansville motorcycle accident has taken from you, you could potentially be awarded the resources necessary to become whole again.

Reach Out to Our Evansville Motorcycle Accident Lawyers

Hensley Legal Group has been fiercely advocating for hardworking Hoosiers like you for more than 25 years. If your world has been turned upside down by a motorcycle accident in Evansville traffic, reach out to our Evansville motorcycle accident lawyers to discover how they can set things right.

For a free consultation with an accomplished Evansville motorcycle accident attorney, please call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form now.