Do I Need to Hire an Indianapolis Personal Injury Lawyer?

March 13, 2025

With a population of nearly 900,000, serious accidents may be inevitable in Indianapolis, but you might have grounds for a personal injury case when somebody else is to blame for your accident.  Very often, injured Indianapolis residents reach out to attorneys to help them with their claims, though you may be wondering “Do I need to hire an Indianapolis personal injury lawyer, or can I get justice on my own?”  Let Hensley Legal Group explain the value of seeking skilled legal assistance for your case. 

The Challenges of Going It Alone After an Injury 

While you are certainly entitled to go it alone after an injury, you could soon run into a host of challenges if you attempt to do so. 

Every personal injury case must demonstrate two core elements: negligence, which is the failure to exercise sufficient care to avoid inflicting harm, and damages, which are the detrimental consequences of that negligence.  Essentially, if you sustain physical damages because of a defendant’s negligence, you could go after that defendant for financial damages. 

Yet the sheer number of possible defendants can be overwhelming, even in something as seemingly straightforward as a car crash. Moreover, the list of candidates may only continue to grow when the accident involves more parties, like in a construction site disaster, and assigning blame may become harder if the causality is less direct, as in a slip-and-fall.  In some instances, multiple defendants could share varying degrees of liability for the same accidental injury, and you must go after them all within the time allotted by law or be forever barred from full fiscal recovery. 

Assuming you somehow manage to identify and take action against each of the defendants before the window of opportunity closes, you may still face stiff opposition from their insurance companies, who have a strong incentive to pay out as little as they can on your case.  This may be your first major injury, but it won’t be the first for a veteran insurance adjuster, who could exploit your relative inexperience to resolve your claim for less or merely deny it altogether, which could leave you with few options if you are already teetering on the brink of ruin. 

How an Indianapolis Personal Injury Attorney Can Make a Difference 

The odds are frequently against you when you are handling a personal injury case by yourself, and one false move could sink your claim before it has really begun, but an Indianapolis personal injury attorney can make a difference. 

Just as it won’t be the first accidental injury for the adjuster, it also won’t be the first for your lawyer, who will be much better equipped to meet the insurers on a level playing field, assess what your case is truly worth, and contend with every obstacle in order to equal or exceed that figure.  This is a key reason why personal injury victims receive 3.5 times more on average with attorneys than they do without them. 

Once retained, your Indianapolis personal injury lawyer will launch a thorough investigation into your accident and the defendants who contributed to it, then establish valid claims against them and potentially file a lawsuit as well in a court with the authority to issue a binding judgment. 

Additionally, your attorney will move swiftly to amass the materials required to build a rock-solid case before negotiating tirelessly with the defendants’ insurance carriers for a settlement that reflects the totality of your losses, including your: 

• Medical bills 

• Lost income 

• Pain and suffering 

• Mental and emotional trauma 

• Mobility restrictions 

• Scarring and disfigurement 

• Loss of consortium 

When confronted with compelling proof of both your damages and the insured’s culpability, a wise adjuster may decide to extend a generous offer rather than risk a worse verdict at trial. 

In fact, many Indianapolis personal injury claims can be brought to an amicable conclusion prior to trial.  However, a battle-tested lawyer will be indispensable if your case has its day in the courtroom, where unrepresented plaintiffs lose about 96 percent of the time, but plaintiffs with professional representation are statistically favored to prevail.  

And if your Indianapolis personal injury attorney can make a receptive jury understand everything that has been taken from you, you might be awarded the resources necessary to become whole again. 

Get in Touch with Our Indianapolis Personal Injury Lawyers 

Hensley Legal Group has been fiercely advocating for the wrongfully injured for more than 25 years.  If you have been badly hurt in the Indianapolis area through no fault of your own, get in touch with our Indianapolis personal injury lawyers to learn about the remedies that may be available to you. 

To schedule a free consultation with a dedicated Indianapolis personal injury attorney, you can call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form now.