When Is the Right Time to Call an Evansville, IN Car Accident Attorney?

January 17, 2026

Car accidents may be inevitable in Evansville, IN, where more than twelve collisions per day took place in the most recent year on record, and the injuries they inflict could potentially stretch a family’s finances to the breaking point. Fortunately, compensation may be available when somebody else is responsible for a crash on an Evansville road like I-69, and you could increase the amount you obtain by joining forces with a lawyer, but when is the right time to call an Evansville, IN car accident attorney? Discover why you shouldn’t put off seeking legal assistance for an auto injury.

You Might Have Less Time Than You Think

We definitely won’t put off giving you an answer to this question, so here it is: NOW is the right time to call the sort of skilled Evansville, IN car accident lawyer you’d find at Hensley Legal Group, PC, a dedicated Indiana personal injury law firm whose experienced attorneys have been fighting on behalf of the wrongfully injured since 1998.

Because while you may have up to two years under Indiana law to take legal action over a car accident, that might add up to less time than you think because of the many challenges that may lay ahead of you, including the challenge of simply identifying everyone who may be at fault. On top of the driver who hit you and the owner of his or her vehicle, a host of other defendants could share varying levels of blame as well, and you could be forever barred from getting fairly compensated if you don’t pursue them all.

And if you do manage to track down each of the defendants, you will probably face stiff resistance from their insurance carriers, who will generally be your primary sources of fiscal recovery and who could begin mounting a strong defense while you’re still struggling to regain your bearings. Whether by casting doubt on a defendant’s liability or the nature and extent of your losses, a veteran insurance adjuster could easily exploit your relative unfamiliarity with the claims process to resolve your claim for pennies on the dollar, assuming it isn’t merely denied altogether.

If that should happen, you and the people you love could find yourselves teetering on the brink of ruin, but a knowledgeable legal practitioner can help you get on solid ground again.

What an Evansville, IN Car Accident Lawyer Can Do for You

A seasoned Evansville, IN car accident lawyer will have what it takes to meet the insurance companies on a level playing field and fend off the tricks and tactics that they might otherwise deploy against a novice plaintiff such as yourself. Your attorney will also be better able to calculate what your case is really worth and will always strive to equal or exceed that figure, a key reason why injured victims with lawyers receive 3.5 times more on average than injured victims without them.

A tenacious attorney will unearth the root causes of your car accident and the defendants who may have contributed to it, establish valid claims and/or file suit against them, and secure irrefutable evidence of their negligence, possibly from the accident site if he or she is retained soon enough.

After assembling an airtight case, your lawyer will negotiate tirelessly with the defendants’ insurers for a settlement that reflects the totality of your damages, including your:

• Medical bills
• Lost wages
• Pain and suffering
• Mental and emotional trauma
• Mobility restrictions
• Scarring and disfigurement
• Diminished quality of living
• Loss of consortium (if applicable)

Although the vast majority of car accident cases can be brought to amicable conclusions without ever going to trial, a battle-tested attorney will be indispensable if a trial becomes necessary, since approximately 96 percent of plaintiffs who represent themselves in the courtroom lose. In contrast, plaintiffs with professional representation are statistically favored to win and might even be awarded the resources they need to get their lives back on track.

As you can see, the difference between a claim you handle on your own and a claim you put into the hands of a capable car accident lawyer can be as stark as the difference between night and day, so make this the day you choose to get out of the dark and hire one.

Get in Touch with Our Evansville, IN Car Accident Attorneys

Hensley Legal Group has been standing up for seriously injured Hoosiers like you for over a quarter century. If you’re not sure what to do or where to turn after a devastating car accident in the Evansville area, get in touch with our Evansville, IN car accident attorneys to learn more about your legal options.

Just call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form for a no-cost case review with an accomplished Evansville, IN car accident lawyer at our firm.