What Questions Should I Ask an Indiana Personal Injury Lawyer?

September 30, 2025

If you have been seriously injured in Indiana as a result of someone else’s negligence, hiring a skilled personal injury lawyer can make a huge difference in the outcome of any case you might have.  But with so many attorneys promoting their services, it can be tough to know which one may be suited to represent you, though asking questions could lay the foundation for a sound decision. 

At Hensley Legal Group, PC, a dedicated Indiana personal injury law firm whose experienced attorneys have been fighting on behalf of the wrongfully injured since 1998, we realize how overwhelming the legal system can be.  This is why we want to equip injured Hoosiers with the information necessary to select capable legal assistance, so join us as we discuss some topics you should bring up if you are wondering “What questions should I ask an Indiana personal injury lawyer?”  

Making Sure That a Personal Injury Lawyer Is a Good Fit 

Meeting with prospective Indiana personal injury attorneys can give you a chance to assess their qualifications as well as their commitment to your case, and an initial consultation can allow you to make sure that a candidate is a good fit for you and your needs.  Before you sign a retainer agreement, consider asking these essential questions: 

• How long have you been practicing personal injury law in Indiana?
  Local knowledge is crucial, and a lawyer who has practiced personal injury law in Indiana for a number of years or even decades might have a deeper understanding of the state’s courtroom procedures. 
• Have you handled cases like mine before?
  Every case is unique, but an attorney who has handled cases like yours before may have a significantly higher likelihood of success. 
• What is your approach to personal injury claims?
  Whereas some lawyers might push for quick settlements, others may be more aggressive about taking cases to trial, and inquiring about an attorney’s approach could help align your expectations. 
• How will you keep me in the loop on my case?
  Because open communication is vital, you should confirm that a lawyer has a process in place to keep you in the loop. 
• Do you work on a contingency basis?
  Most personal injury attorneys, including those at Hensley Legal Group, operate on a contingency basis, meaning that you won’t have to pay them unless your case is won, though it’s important to verify the fee structure up front. 
• What is my case worth?
  This is something of a trick question, since too many factors may still be unknown about your case at this point to calculate its worth.  While a lawyer can offer a general idea based on prior claims, any attorney who names an exact figure is potentially being either deceptive or naïve. 
• How long will my case take?
  Once again, be wary of lawyers making concrete guarantees, as the timeline can vary greatly depending upon the specifics of your situation. 

Taking the opportunity to ask these questions can give you a clearer picture of whether an attorney is someone you can trust with your case.  Ultimately, the right lawyer will welcome your questions and give you honest answers, leaving you feeling confident in that attorney’s abilities and comfortable with how your case will be managed.  And when you’re dealing with the stress of a catastrophic injury, that kind of peace of mind can be invaluable. 

Why These Questions Matter 

The answers to these questions can provide critical insight into how a law firm operates, how much attention your case will receive, and how well a lawyer knows Indiana’s judicial landscape. At Hensley Legal Group, we believe that informed clients are empowered clients, and we’re here to make the road ahead as straightforward as possible. 

Regardless if your injury stems from a car accident on I-70 or a fall at an Indianapolis grocery store, it’s crucial to work with an attorney who not only knows Indiana law but also knows how to get you fairly compensated.  Asking smart questions at the beginning can set the tone for a fruitful collaboration and ensure that your legal team is ready to go the distance for you. 

Get in Touch with Our Indiana Personal Injury Lawyers 

Choosing an attorney in the wake of a major injury isn’t about simply looking at credentials or commercials.  It’s about finding someone who will advocate tirelessly for your interests – someone like the seasoned legal professionals at Hensley Legal Group, who have been getting justice for injured clients for over a quarter century.  If you have been badly hurt in Indiana through no fault of your own, get in touch with our Indiana personal injury lawyers to learn what they can do for you. 

To schedule a free case review with an accomplished Indiana personal injury attorney, please call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form now.