Is Hiring an Evansville Car Accident Lawyer Worth It?

July 3, 2025

Car crashes are unfortunate yet common occurrences on Evansville roadways. Most collisions are just minor fender benders, but others can have a ripple effect on numerous aspects of their victims’ lives. If you were hurt in a car accident in the Evansville, IN area and are contemplating a personal injury case, you might be wondering, “Is hiring an Evansville car accident lawyer worth it?” Join Hensley Legal Group as we discuss how partnering with a qualified attorney can be the most effective way to recoup fair compensation for your losses following an accident.

What an Evansville Car Accident Lawyer Can Do for You

When you’re on your own following an Evansville car accident, you might not be aware of your rights, the true value of your damages, or all of your legal options, and insurance companies may take advantage of your lack of knowledge to resolve your claim for less. Most insurance carriers have adjusters on staff who have years of experience handing claim evaluations under their belts and will always try to protect their employers’ interests, even if it means paying you the bare minimum.

However, having a lawyer on your side could level the playing field. Your attorney can begin an investigation immediately, gathering evidence of the negligent actions that injured you. This investigation may involve:

Getting the police report for your crash
Examining the scene where the incident occurred
Talking to eyewitnesses
Assessing the totality of your losses

Your lawyer will also manage all communications with other parties on your behalf, pushing back whenever an adjuster tries to pressure you into accepting pennies on the dollar for your claim.

Signs That Retaining an Attorney Makes Sense for You

While a car accident attorney can be useful in many circumstances, you should especially consider retaining one in the following situations:

You Don’t Have a Strong Understanding of the Legal System – Most people don’t know much about personal injury law, and the process by which a claim must be pursued can vary depending on where you live. If you are not familiar with local regulations, it can be tough to know what to do or what the initial steps are.
You Have Multiple Damages – After a collision, you may be owed payment for both special (economic) damages, like your medical costs and the wages you have lost, and general (non-economic) damages, like disfigurement and pain and suffering.
Your Claim Is Denied or You’re Offered a Low Settlement – There are a number of reasons why the claim you filed might get denied or you might get offered a low settlement that might as well be a denial, but a lawyer can boost your chances of approval from the beginning. According to the Insurance Research Council, accident victims with legal representation have been shown to receive 3.5 times more on average than those who choose to manage their claims independently.
The Insurance Company Won’t Negotiate – In some scenarios, an insurance company may refuse to speak with you further or at all. If this happens and you want to continue fighting for your rights, you will need an attorney who can advocate for you in court.

As you can see, several obstacles can arise when you seek justice for a personal injury, but joining forces with a seasoned legal practitioner can allow you to overcome them.

How to Find a Good Lawyer in Evansville

Finding a good Evansville car accident lawyer can be just as challenging as squaring off against the defendant, since there are many dodgy law firms out there that prioritize making money off their clients over serving them. To avoid working with a subpar legal team, there are key elements that you should remember to take into account:

The case results and historic success of the team
How long the law firm has been in practice
The team’s dedication to your case
How quickly your concerns are addressed
The firm’s reputation, as reflected in client testimonials and news publications
The availability of a free consultation

In addition, personal injury firms usually operate on a contingency basis, meaning they are only paid once a favorable outcome is achieved, so be wary of any attorneys who demand payment up front.

Contact Our Evansville Car Accident Lawyers Today

It can be overwhelming to figure out what to do after getting hit by a car, but you may be able to get the settlement or verdict you deserve if you contact our Evansville car accident lawyers today. Whether navigating the intricacies of the claims process, contending with the insurers, or helping you get vital medical treatment for your injuries, Hensley Legal Group will be here for you in Evansville and the surrounding areas.

To schedule a free case review with a dedicated Evansville car accident attorney, please call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form now.