Indiana’s Most Dangerous Roads for Car and Truck Accidents

February 24, 2026

• State highways have been found to be the most dangerous roads for car and truck accidents in Indiana, with I-65 recording the most traffic deaths in a five-year period.
• A relatively small number of Indiana roads contribute to a disproportionately large number of fatalities, often because of design features that encourage reckless driving.
• Yet no matter where a crash occurs, the Indiana car and truck accident lawyers at Hensley Legal Group, PC will always fight to get you the compensation you deserve.

While a car or truck accident could happen anywhere in Indiana, a new study has found that motorists tend to be less safe in some areas than in others, though compensation may be available if somebody else is at fault for an accident that injures you, regardless of where it occurs. Moreover, retaining skilled legal assistance might increase the amount you obtain, so read on to discover what Indiana’s most dangerous roads for car and truck accidents are as well as what a lawyer can do for your own accident.

Indiana Car and Truck Accidents Are Deadliest on State Highways

In December 2025, the online insurance comparison service iSelect published a comprehensive examination of “the riskiest locations to drive” in the United States, the U.K., and Australia, drawing upon statistics from the most recent five-year period on record. The information outlined in the report was incredibly precise, with the data broken down to the street level.

State highways were revealed to be the most likely sites of deadly crashes, both in Indiana and throughout the country, a conclusion that might be unsurprising based upon their higher speed limits, more frequent intersections, and minimal separations between a wider range of vehicles. However, it should be noted that state highways in Indiana accounted for a lower percentage of vehicular fatalities than the national average, making up 33 percent of Indiana traffic deaths as opposed to 42 percent nationwide.

Local streets were the second deadliest types of roads in Indiana, playing a role in 28 percent of the state’s automotive casualties, followed by U.S. highways (22 percent) and interstates (17 percent).

Overall, Indiana witnessed 4,183 lethal collisions from 2020 through 2024, and a distressingly small number of roads were home to a distressingly large number of tragedies. And given how many fatal crashes took place on them, iSelect determined that the ten most dangerous roads for car and truck accidents in the State of Indiana were:

1. I-65 (93 incidents resulting in death)
2. I-80 (62)
3. U.S. 31 (56)
4. I-69 (48) – tie
I-70 (48) – tie
U.S. 41 (48) – tie
7. U.S. 20 (43)
8. Indiana 37 (41)
9. I-465 (37)
10. Indiana 67 (33)

In discussing these findings, the general manager of general insurance at iSelect pointed out that a variety of factors could put drivers and passengers in jeopardy, but they can usually be reduced to a single one: the human factor.

“Road safety isn’t defined by weather or road conditions alone; it ultimately depends on the behaviour of drivers and staying alert to your surroundings and anticipating potential hazards, whether that’s pedestrians, other vehicles, poor visibility or changing road surfaces, is essential,” he explained. “Following speed limits, taking regular breaks on long journeys, and keeping a safe distance from other vehicles can make all the difference in preventing collisions.”

How an Indiana Car and Truck Accident Attorney Can Help

Although that’s certainly sound advice, it unfortunately won’t prevent every accident on every Indiana road. Nevertheless, you can get yourself back on the road to recovery with help from a respected practice like Hensley Legal Group, PC, a dedicated Indiana personal injury law firm whose experienced attorneys have been fighting on behalf of the wrongfully injured since 1998.

Your lawyer will begin by carrying out a thorough investigation into your Indiana car or truck accident, identifying the defendants responsible for it, and establishing valid claims and/or filing suit against each of them within the time allotted by law.

A tenacious Indiana car and truck accident attorney will also move swiftly to amass the evidentiary materials needed to build a rock-solid case against the defendants, then negotiate fiercely with their insurance companies for a settlement that reflects the entirety of your losses.

When confronted with irrefutable proof of both your damages and the defendants’ misconduct, a sensible insurer may decide to propose a generous settlement in order to avoid a worse verdict. This is a key reason why 85 percent of the funds that these insurers pay out go to claimants with lawyers, though a battle-tested attorney will be indispensable if a trial becomes necessary.

Whereas 96 percent of plaintiffs who represent themselves in court lose, professionally represented plaintiffs are favored to win and might even manage to secure verdicts substantial enough to make them whole again.

Reach Out to Hensley’s Indiana Car and Truck Accident Lawyers

Hensley Legal Group has been getting justice for the innocent victims of negligence for over a quarter century. If you’ve been badly hurt by a car or truck in the Hoosier State, reach out to Hensley’s Indiana car and truck accident lawyers to learn more about your legal options.

You can schedule a free case review with a knowledgeable Indiana car and truck accident attorney by calling us at (317) 472-3333, chatting with us online, or filling out our contact form now.