How Much Does an Indiana Car Accident Lawyer Charge for a Car Accident?

Car accidents in Indiana are often physically and financially catastrophic, but you may have grounds for a personal injury case when somebody else is at fault for a collision on an Indiana road like the 465. Moreover, you could improve your chances of success considerably if you reach out to a knowledgeable legal practitioner, but […]

October 23, 2025

Couldn’t You Just Represent Yourself?

Before we delve into the cost of retaining an Indiana car accident attorney, you may be wondering whether you should retain one at all. Couldn’t you just represent yourself?

Though you certainly have the right to go it alone in the wake of an Indiana car accident, you could run into various difficulties if you try to do so, especially when it comes to the insurance companies for the parties who harmed you, who will generally be your chief sources of fiscal recovery.

This may be your first serious collision, but it definitely won’t be the first for a veteran insurance adjuster. Consequently, your relative unfamiliarity with the claims process could be exploited to resolve your claim for less than it’s worth, assuming it isn’t merely denied altogether.

This inherent imbalance in information is a key reason why injured victims who don’t hire lawyers receive 3.5 times less on average than victims who do, and the situation may get even worse if your case makes it to a courtroom, where about 96 percent of plaintiffs without attorneys lose.

As you can see, you are likely to be at a huge disadvantage if you pursue a car accident claim on your own. However, the advantage could be yours if you partner with the kind of seasoned lawyer you’d find at Hensley Legal Group, PC, a dedicated Indiana personal injury law firm whose experienced attorneys have been fighting on behalf of the wrongfully injured since 1998.

And if you’re concerned about committing to more expenditures when you have spent so much already, you should be aware that you probably won’t be asked for anything up front because the vast majority of lawyers who handle cases like yours operate on a contingency basis.

What a Contingency Fee Arrangement Can Do for You

Under a contingency fee arrangement, an attorney’s payment is dependent or “contingent” upon the outcome of a claim, so you should not have to turn over any funds before your lawyer agrees to get started.

Once the paperwork has been signed, your attorney will launch an investigation into your Indiana car accident, identify the defendants who caused it, establish valid claims and/or file suit against them, and amass the evidentiary materials necessary to support any allegations you make, such as:

Police reports
Citations and dispositions
Witness statements
Crash site photos
Dash cam, traffic light, and surveillance footage
Black box data
Phone records
Driving histories
Maintenance logs
Accident reconstruction and forensic analysis

When faced with irrefutable proof of both the extent of your losses and the depth of the defendants’ misconduct, a sensible insurer might be convinced to put forth a generous offer. If not, your lawyer can proceed to trial in order to get you compensated for the entirety of your damages, including your:

Medical bills
Lost wages
Pain and suffering
Psychological trauma
Mobility restrictions
Scarring and disfigurement
Diminished quality of living
Loss of consortium (when applicable)

Only when a favorable conclusion has been achieved will reimbursement be sought for out-of-pocket expenses along with the fee for services rendered. Usually, this fee will be taken as a fixed percentage of your verdict or settlement, which will statistically be much higher if you have a tenacious Indiana car accident attorney in your corner.

Put simply, your lawyer won’t get paid until you get paid, and the more you get paid, the more he or she will get paid. A mutually beneficial system such as this can further motivate your attorney to maximize the value of your case while also sparing you any additional stress during a uniquely stressful period.

Neither you nor your bank account may have been prepared for the havoc that your car accident has wreaked on your life, but that doesn’t mean you can’t still obtain the compensation you deserve.

Get in Touch with Our Indiana Car Accident Lawyers

Hensley Legal Group has been standing up for honest Hoosiers like you for nearly three decades. If you are struggling to get back to normal after being badly hurt in an Indiana car accident, get in touch with our Indiana car accident lawyers to discover the remedies that may be available to you.

You can call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form for a free case review with an accomplished Indiana car accident attorney now.