Do I Need to Hire an Investigator After a Muncie, IN Truck Accident?

February 19, 2026

• Justice is often elusive after a truck accident in Muncie, IN because the defendants’ insurers could have their investigators on the job in a matter of hours.
• And while it may be tempting to hire an investigator of your own, affording one tends to be difficult even under the best of circumstances.
• Fortunately, you can enjoy the same level of investigative services if you retain the Muncie, IN truck accident lawyers at Hensley Legal Group, PC.

The consequences are usually dire when a large truck or semi-trailer hits your car in Muncie, IN, whether the collision takes place on a quiet residential street or a busy highway like SR-3. And while you may have grounds to pursue a personal injury case if somebody else is at fault, its success often hinges on the quality of the evidence you’re able to secure, though you don’t have to secure it alone. Learn how a knowledgeable lawyer can help if you’re asking yourself “Do I need to hire an investigator after a Muncie, IN truck accident?”

You Could Be at a Distinct Disadvantage When Assigning Blame

To be viable, a personal injury case must allege two core elements: negligence – the failure to exercise sufficient care to avoid harming others – and damages – the detrimental effects of that negligence. To put it plainly, if you suffer physical damages as a result of a defendant’s negligence, you should be eligible to go after that defendant for financial damages.

Because a commercial truck can weigh 20 to 30 times more than the average passenger vehicle, damages are practically inevitable in the event of a Muncie, IN truck accident, though negligence might be another story entirely.

In fact, when it comes to assigning blame, you are probably at a distinct disadvantage compared to the defendants’ insurance companies, who will generally be your main sources of fiscal recovery and may have upwards of $5 million in applicable coverage depending upon what’s being hauled.

That’s five million reasons to build an airtight defense that could justify resolving your case for as little as possible. Moreover, an insurance carrier could begin mounting that defense in the immediate aftermath of your truck accident, including by dispatching a team to investigate the scene while you may still be undergoing emergency medical treatment or simply trying to regain your bearings.

Assuming you do somehow manage to investigate the truck accident in a timely fashion, it might not do that much good if you don’t have a solid idea what you should be looking for. In contrast, a veteran insurance investigator will know exactly what kind of proof would be favorable to the defense and unfavorable to you – as well as exactly how to find it.

How a Muncie, IN Truck Accident Attorney Can Make a Difference

But is the deck hopelessly stacked against you if you don’t hire your own investigator, someone you might have trouble affording even under normal circumstances? Not if you retain a respected practice like Hensley Legal Group, PC, a dedicated Indiana personal injury law firm whose experienced attorneys have been fighting on behalf of the wrongfully injured since 1998.

A seasoned lawyer can launch a comprehensive investigation to unearth the root causes of your Muncie, IN truck accident and the defendants responsible for it. Critical evidentiary materials capable of supporting any allegations of negligence that you make can also be amassed, potentially from the crash site itself if you partner with an attorney soon enough, such as:

• Photos and videos
• Black box data
• Eyewitness statements
• Police reports
• Citations and dispositions
• Phone records
• Hours of Service (HOS) and maintenance logs

If you’re worried about committing to more expenditures after you have spent so much already, you may be happy to hear that the vast majority of Muncie, IN truck accident lawyers operate on a contingency basis. This means that you shouldn’t be charged anything up front before an attorney agrees to start working on your case, and some of the associated costs may be taken care of too, including the cost of commissioning an outside investigator or forensic expert if the situation should warrant it.

Only when an amicable conclusion is reached will reimbursement be sought for the out-of-pocket expenses incurred and a fee for the services rendered, typically as a percentage of a verdict or settlement that is statistically likely to be 3.5 times higher if you have a lawyer in your corner.

It’s a mutually beneficial arrangement that could allow you to enjoy the advantages that a skilled investigator can offer without having to come up with the money to hire one first, so go out and join forces with a Muncie, IN truck accident attorney and begin enjoying them now!

Get in Touch with Hensley’s Muncie, IN Truck Accident Lawyers Today

Hensley Legal Group has been fiercely advocating for seriously injured Hoosiers like you for more than 25 years. If you’re not sure what to do or where to turn after being badly hurt by a reckless trucker in the Muncie area, get in touch with Hensley’s Muncie, IN truck accident lawyers today to explore your legal options.

Just call us at (317) 472-3333, chat with us online, or fill out our contact form to schedule a free case review with an accomplished Muncie, IN truck accident attorney at our firm.