Why Choosing the Right Evansville Personal Injury Lawyer Matters

October 7, 2025

An accidental injury always seems to be just around the corner in a city the size of Evansville, whether because of a car crash on I-69, a disaster at a local construction site, or a slip-and-fall in a private home or a commercial business. Fortunately, compensation may be available when somebody else is at fault, and a capable attorney can increase the amount you obtain, though it is critical to hire one who is best suited for your case, so join us to learn why choosing the right Evansville personal injury lawyer matters.

The Benefits of Securing Legal Assistance in the Wake of a Major Accident

Before delving into the value of selecting the correct attorney for the job, it is worth understanding the benefits of securing legal assistance in the wake of a major accident, since you could soon run into serious obstacles if you decide to go it alone.

To be viable, any personal injury case must demonstrate two core elements: negligence – the failure to exercise sufficient caution to avoid harming others – and damages – the detrimental outcomes of that negligence. Basically, if you suffer physical damages because of a defendant’s negligence, you could go after that defendant for financial damages, but merely identifying every defendant can be tough. Very often, multiple defendants may share liability simultaneously, and they must each be pursued within the time allotted by law or you could be forever barred from getting fully compensated.

And if you do somehow manage to track down every defendant who contributed to your injury, you will probably still encounter stiff resistance from the insurance companies with applicable coverage. A veteran insurance adjuster could easily exploit your relative unfamiliarity with the process to resolve your claim for less or simply deny it altogether.

But if the deck can be stacked against you if you proceed with a personal injury claim by yourself, you can be dealt a winning hand if you partner with a lawyer who is equipped to fend off the tricks and tactics that insurance carriers frequently deploy against novice claimants. This is a key reason why personal injury victims statistically receive 3.5 times more with attorneys than they do without them.

An Evansville personal injury lawyer can also investigate your accident, unearth its root causes and the defendants responsible for it, establish valid claims and/or file suit against them, and amass compelling evidence of both the depth of their misconduct and the extent of your losses.

After assembling an airtight personal injury case, a seasoned legal practitioner can either negotiate for a fair settlement or advocate for you in the courtroom, where about 96 percent of unrepresented plaintiffs lose but plaintiffs with professional representation are favored to prevail.

Not All Attorneys Are Created Equal

Hopefully, the advantages of teaming up with an attorney have become clear, though it should be noted that not all attorneys are created equal.

More than 15,000 lawyers are currently licensed in the State of Indiana, and they each have different strengths, different weaknesses, and, perhaps most importantly, different areas of practice. The truth is that every kind of case has unique requirements that must be met and unique challenges that must be overcome, and it can take years or even decades to hone the skills necessary to address them.

Consequently, an attorney who may be highly adept in family law might have no idea how to approach your truck accident case, so you should look for a lawyer who has a proven record of success with similar claims. With this in mind, you can begin by seeking out recommendations from people you know who have had Evansville personal injury cases in the past or by searching the internet for attorneys in the vicinity who handle cases with fact patterns like yours.

You can then narrow down the list of candidates by reading online testimonials, paying close attention to lawyers who garner consistent praise, like the lawyers at Hensley Legal Group, PC, a dedicated Indiana personal injury law firm whose experienced attorneys have been fighting on behalf of the wrongfully injured since 1998. Our firm is proud to have earned an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars from more than 4,000 Google reviews left by clients who were profoundly satisfied with the help we provided them when they needed it most.

Reach Out to Our Tenacious Evansville Personal Injury Lawyers

Hensley Legal Group has been getting justice for Hoosiers injured in nearly every circumstance imaginable for over a quarter century. If you are struggling to get back to normal after being grievously hurt in Evansville, reach out to our tenacious Evansville personal injury lawyers to explore your legal options.

You can arrange a free case review with a knowledgeable Evansville personal injury attorney by calling us at (317) 472-3333, chatting with us online, or filling out our contact form today.